Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Cleaning sodium metal?

woelen - 8-2-2010 at 02:04

I purchased well over 100 grams of very old sodium metal for just EUR 5, stored under old yellow/brown petroleum (yikes! bad smell). The sodium was really really dirty, it was covered by a thick crust of brown smelly stuff, most likely from the dirty oil under which it was stored. This brown stuff certainly is not sodium peroxide nor sodium superoxide.

I peeled all pieces of sodium like a potato with a sharp knife, using latex gloves while doing this, and rinsed the metal with clean high quality paraffin oil and now I have around 75 grams of nice and clean sodium under colorless pure paraffin oil. It is a pleasure to look at that nice and clean material :D

I still have 25 (maybe even 35) grams of all the waste sodium turnings stored under its brown petroleum. It is a terrible mess. I intended to throw away this mess, by rinsing it with some volatile petroleum ether and then dumping all sodium at once in a small lake or something like that, but I think it is a waste of precious sodium metal. After removing the crusts, I'm sure I will have another 20 to 30 grams of sodium.

How could the sodium be cleaned in a safe way? I tried putting some of the turnings in IPA, but this does not really work. It gives a dirty brown mess and eats away the sodium, but the crust does not really separate. The resulting liquid also is not interesting, it is dirty brown and turbid, not an interesting solution of sodium isopropylate.

In another experiment I put some of the turnings in a test tube and added some of the petroleum and carefully heated until the sodium melts. When this is done, many small globules are formed (appr. 4 mm diameter) with still some of the dirty brown stuff attached to the globules. The globules do not combine to one big ball :( If I do this on a larger scale, do you expect the sodium to combine into a few bigger balls?

Any ideas of how to proceed, or should I indeed make one final firework of the sodium by dumping it in the water?

Jor - 8-2-2010 at 03:40

Why don't you melt the entire batch under parrafin (or xylene as it is done usually, but this is flammable, and I don't like molten alkali metals under flammables), and try to remove the dirty stuff mechanically, with a pair of tweezers or something like that.

This brown stuff must be some non-volatile hydrocarbon I think. It should dissolve in petroleum ether, of if not try toluene or ether or something like that? Otherwise, what could the brown mess be? Was the bottle opened already?

woelen - 8-2-2010 at 04:43

The brown stuff is not soluble in hydrocarbons. The bottle once was opened, but probably not for the last 30 years or so. As stated, the sodium was stored under yellow/brown petroleum, not under nice clear paraffin oil. The petroleum contains a lot of colored chemicals, it is impure and may contain sulphur compounds and many other bad stuff (try to imagine how petroleum looked like 50 years ago, this was a not so nice liquid in those days ;), which when burnt gave off a smelly pungent smoke). When this petroleum is heated, then it smells like I have a leaking USSR-type oil refinery in my backyard :D

Mechanical separation is not an option, the dirty brown stuff forms a sticky and flocculent mass around the sodium when it is heated. It becomes hard and brittle again when it cools down.

mr.crow - 8-2-2010 at 08:08

Have you read Len1's excellent sodium thread? https://www.sciencemadness.org/whisper/viewthread.php?tid=97...

He was successful using parafin oil to clean oxidation and coalesce the globules at high temperature.

Leaking soviet oil refinery, haha!

woelen - 8-2-2010 at 11:21

Thanks for the link. I melted my sodium on a heater under the dirty petroleum. It formed many globules, appr. 5 mm in diameter and a few bigger ones. Unfortunately, I could not heat all the way up to 140 C or so, because the petroleum started boiling well below this temperature, giving off horrible white smoke and strong smell. Besides that, the brown material started charring. I could, however, get rid of most of the dirty crap. I sieved out the globules of sodium metal and certainly 95% could be recovered. The smallest globules (some less than 1 mm in diameter) I just dumped, together with the black charred goo and the brown petroleum. I now have some of the sodium under the remaining petroleum, and I intend to do a second cleanup.

The picture below shows the sodium after this first treatment. The amount of brown and black goo was about the same as the amount of sodium, so I think that I already have a much better situation :) The big globule in the picture is about 1.5 cm diameter, the medium sized ones are 6 mm in diameter.

sodium.jpg - 65kB


Right now it is very cold (-7 degrees and a lot of wind), so the second phase of cleanup will be when the weather outside is somewhat more pleasant.



[Edited on 8-2-10 by woelen]

woelen - 9-2-2010 at 02:40

It is quite remarkable what happened here. On standing in the cold, the remaining small amount of crusts on the globules of sodium just cracked off, leaving perfectly clean sodium behind :). When I saw this, I was pleased very much. I have taken the jar, as shown in the picture above and have shaken it for some time to help this process a little bit and then allowed to settle again. And guess what? Very nice shiny globules of sodium can be separated easily from this dirty yellow petroleum and the remaining brown goop.

I took a little beaker and put in some clean colorless high quality paraffin oil. With a little spoon I collected all sodium from the dirty oil and transferred it to the clean oil. I swirled this beaker with oil and sodium and then again I transferred the sodium to yet another beaker with fresh clean paraffin oil and now it is totally clean. Nice and somewhat shiny globules under a layer of perfectly clear and colorless oil. No need to perform another melt and solidify cycle, as I first intended to do.

sodiumclean.jpg - 59kB


I certainly recovered 90% of the waste sodium, probably even more, with just a single pass of heating, like Len1 has done. I have tested a few globules for purity by putting them in a little water after removal of the adhering oil with a tissue. The sodium melts while frothing around on the water surface and while doing so, it dissolves giving a solution of NaOH. What remains is a colorless solution. No yellow/brown junk at all.





[Edited on 9-2-10 by woelen]

mr.crow - 9-2-2010 at 15:21

Congrats :) Some extra sodium is always nice

chemoleo - 9-2-2010 at 16:57

So how wil you get the sodium 'bubbles' to coalesce, to fuse? From my experience, that's where the problem resides. On the other hand, the blobs aren't submillimeter size, so mechanical stirring should help I suppose.

Very nice pics, it lifts my heart seeing this!

Geeks come forth! :)

chemrox - 9-2-2010 at 17:30

Please do not contaminate a lake with it. There are numerous beings in any pond or lake that are dependent on a stable pH. Melt the shit under inert atmosphere or motor oil.

woelen - 10-2-2010 at 02:03

@chemoleo: I leave the sodium as it is now, no need to have the spheres coalesce into bigger ones. I do like the small spheres of sodium. They are around 5 mm diameter and this is quite convenient. If I want to do a little demo experiment (e.g. for the kids), then I just take out a single 'bubble', wipe off the paraffin oil and throw it in some water. For experiments this also is convenient, just take out the number of bubbles you need, rinse them with petroleum ether to get rid of the oil and then add them to the reaction mixture. No need to cut sodium metal into smaller pieces.

@chemrox: I will not contaminate any lake with the remaining waste. I just put the waste in a plastic bottle which cannot break, and have thrown this in the trash bin. Waste like this will be burned and then the petroleum and the remaining few sub-mm globules of the sodium, mixed with the brown goop, simply will be destroyed in the waste-burning oven. This is safe and probably this is environmentally the best thing.

woelen - 21-2-2010 at 10:52

Now, after two weeks of storage, the sodium has turned a little bit grey. It does not change any further anymore.

This is a picture of the sodium, from which I have cut the dirty brown crust.





And this is the sodium, which I have melted:




As you can see, I have quite a lot of sodium at the moment, altogether it is well over 100 grams of sodium.






[Edited on 21-2-10 by woelen]

mr.crow - 21-2-2010 at 14:55

Ohhh Pretty :)

Does your sodium form bubbles like mine does? I think my oil is still contaminated with water.

The_Davster - 21-2-2010 at 15:16

Bubbles only form if you oil is wet.

A good technique is to treat all new oil with a small amount of sodium for a few days, then when it is dry, use it for storing your sodium.

woelen - 22-2-2010 at 00:45

I only had bubbles the first day. In the first day, I opened the jars every six hours or so, but after two days no new bubbles formed anymore. Right now, the storage solution is stable. I have closed these jar very tightly and quite some force is needed to unscrew the caps. These caps are metal caps with a plastic layer inside and these are closing the jar really well and work exceptionally well for non-corrosive materials. No humidity can enter these jars.

mr.crow - 27-2-2010 at 19:47

Mine was bubbling for months, but it appears to have stopped now

As an experiment I dropped a piece of gray sodium into 100 degree mineral oil. All the white crap instantly came off leaving it nice and shiny. I took it off the hotplate before it melted.

This is a good way to clean the metal before using it.

mr.crow - 1-3-2010 at 19:03

Update: I can see the crystal domains in the sodium, very very nice :)