Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Avoiding over nitration (or generally over-electrophilic substitution)

Monoamine - 20-6-2021 at 12:26

I'm interested in making the para nitro benzoic acid. The generally accepted reaction is below, but I'm somewhat concerned that it might nitrate the ring at the ortho positions too. I certainly don't accidentally want to make some kind of explosive!!

So basically I was hoping to ask, whether there is a risk of sticking on more nitros than wanted, or if there is a reason why only the ortho product is obtained....?



Attachment: Reaction (191kB)
This file has been downloaded 170 times

Boffis - 20-6-2021 at 13:07

Use only a small molar excess of nitric acid that should limit multiple nitration as will lower temperatures. Lower temperatures will also reduce oxidation of the alcohol group.

Monoamine - 20-6-2021 at 15:25

Quote: Originally posted by Boffis  
Use only a small molar excess of nitric acid that should limit multiple nitration as will lower temperatures. Lower temperatures will also reduce oxidation of the alcohol group.


Thank you for the answer!

I looked at the mechanism, and apparently in general one gets a 50/50% (depending where you look) of the 2-nitro and the 4-nitro product.

Do you know how such a mixture is usually separated?


It's not obvious to me how you might separate the two, since (I'm guessing) their solubility properties are the same, and they can't be distilled off either since their boiling points are ginormous.

Oxidizing the OH and then Protecting the ortho positions through sulfonation at the meta positions won't work either (see attached reaction scheme).

So this basically leaves column chromatography, but even that might be hard since they are probably also similarly polar...

Screen Shot 2021-06-20 at 4.15.09 PM.png - 270kB

Purification procedure.

Monoamine - 20-6-2021 at 16:39

Ok, after some research I think that the best way to separate the ortho and the meta product is by freeze distillation:

The ortho product melts at ~ 69-72oC
The para product melts at ~ 92-94oC

I guess the way to do this would be to allow everything to come to room temperature so it "freezes". Wash away and neutralize any remaining acid, etc...
Slowly heat the solids to about 72oC, and drain off the liquid portion. Then increase the temperature to about 95oC and collect the rest.

Probably wanna wash it a few more times to make sure all the acid is gone.

DraconicAcid - 20-6-2021 at 17:19

I suspect that plenty of para will dissolve in the melted ortho.

Fery - 20-6-2021 at 21:32

Why don't you start from toluene? You can crystallize part of the p-nitrotoluene at -15 C
Then you can oxidize it to p-nitrobenzoic acid by refluxing with water solution of KMnO4

Monoamine - 21-6-2021 at 12:20

Quote: Originally posted by DraconicAcid  
I suspect that plenty of para will dissolve in the melted ortho.


I see. So maybe I'm thinking about this the wrong way around...

Maybe it would be better to melt the two products in a solvent in which they are not soluble. (Although I'm guessing that this would form two layers...

Then the solution is cooled very very slowly so that the para product can gently solidify.

Ideally, the solvent used should also be less dense than the liquid nitro compounds, so that any solid ortho product will precipitate to the bottom.

At this point the top molten ortho product is syphoned off and the solids in the solvent layer filtered off.

The ortho product can now simply be left to cool until it solidifies.

For extra purity, this procedure should probably be repeated a few times...