Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Phenol from Paractemol (Acetominophen)

treelike - 21-7-2006 at 01:37

I could do with a tiny bit of Phenol for studying colour changes with mushrooms. Phenol is one of those chemicals (others include FeSO4 and NH3) which produce a colour change when applied to the flesh of certain mushrooms and this can be invaluable in identifying different species which otherwise look the same.

Obviously I only need tiny amounts of Phenol to apply to the mushroom flesh so I was wondering if it could be made from the common (and extremely inexpensive) painkiller Paracetamol? Looking at the formula on this page:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paracetamol

all you would need to do is "break off" the amino bit but then maybe I'm being a bit simplistic.

chromium - 21-7-2006 at 06:26

There is tread about possibility of making phenol from paracetamol. http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=5617

not_important - 21-7-2006 at 19:05

Better done from aspirin, the amino group on doesn't fly off that easily, except with nitrous acid and then you have to work to make sure the NH2 gets replaced with H.

Aromatic carboxylic acids decaboxalate, the more HO- substitutions the easier; gallic acid does so by boiling a solution of it. The thread chromium posted ends up the phenol topic suggesting the decarbox route, before it drifts off into boom making.

If you're feeling experimental, copper ions help some decarboxlations, you might try runs using the cupric salt of salicylic acid, do a run with copper oxide mixed in with sodium salicylicate, and so on.

Vogal has a prep for p-hydroxybenzoinc acid that starts with salicylic acid and cooks off phenol ( 2 Ksalicylicate => phenol + para KO-bzCO2K )

treelike - 22-7-2006 at 12:26

Ah so I should be able to mix some aspirin with NaOH solution, boil off the water and get some phenol distilling over eventually. I'll give it a try.....

not_important - 22-7-2006 at 21:13

If you want to try, you should first dissolve the aspirin in boiling water, filter to get rid of most of the other stuff used to make the tablets, and cool to let the acetal salicylic acid,/ salicylic acid, to crystallize out. And use uncoated aspirin.

Maja - 23-7-2006 at 03:34

Quote:
Originally posted by not_important
If you want to try, you should first dissolve the aspirin in boiling water, filter to get rid of most of the other stuff used to make the tablets, and cool to let the acetal salicylic acid,/ salicylic acid, to crystallize out. And use uncoated aspirin.


Don't take his suggestion... Water doesn't work for that purpose... Use Acetone or IPA. ASA is soluble in Acetone while other impurities aren't..

not_important - 23-7-2006 at 05:38

Actually it does work, for treelike's purposes. They're just going to dump it in aq lye anyhow. Boiling water hydrolyzes it to acetic and salicylic acids, the acetic will partially boil off. 15 ml of boiling water dissolves 1 gr of salicylic acid while it takes something like 450 ml of cold water - check your Merck Index. The junk in the tabs he'll want to get rid of is mostly insoluable in water, microcystalline wax _will_ dissolve in acetone.

Worked for me when de Gaulle was in charge, still worked when Boy Wonder took over in the U.S.

treelike - 23-7-2006 at 08:12

Wow! Thanks for the suggestions. I'll try the water route first as I'm running extremely low on IPA. A bit of colourless or white impurity won't probably be a big problem anyway. Will post a follow up when I get round to doing the experiment.

not_important - 23-7-2006 at 09:58

Note that you are heating something that is alkaline to a fairly high temperature, like the benzoic acid decarboxilation this can be hard on glassware - although not quite as hard as less heat is needed. If you are doing this a lot, or in large batches, making a retort from pipe might be better. For just trying it, or getting aa gram or so of phenol, a run in a test tube is OK.

hodges - 23-7-2006 at 16:18

Quote:
Originally posted by treelike
Ah so I should be able to mix some aspirin with NaOH solution, boil off the water and get some phenol distilling over eventually. I'll give it a try.....


Won't you get the sodium salt of phenol after the initial heating and then need to react with an acid to get the sodium salt of the acid plus phenol?

not_important - 23-7-2006 at 20:32

No. The process from Vogel, using KOH, is

2 Ksalicylicate => phenol + para KO-bzCO2K

You're starting with the salt of the carboxylic acid, the salicylate decaboxylates shedding it's alkali onto another salicylate's phenolic HO- The reaction goes both ways, as this is not being done as a sealed reaction phenol exscapes.

If you use the potassium salts you also get mostly para-hydroxy, sodiumshould give mostly ortho-hydroxy wwhich looks like no change. The hydroxy-acid can be recycled, either by treating it with water+CO2 to free up the phenolic group or by mixing it with the proper amount of salicylic acid to do the same - get the phenolic HO- as HO instead of K/NaO-.

It's only a fair to poor yield, but aspirin is cheap in Europe and NA.

Maja - 24-7-2006 at 01:02

Inactive ingredients in some aspirin tablets.... :

Black iron oxide
Brown iron oxide
Carnauba wax
Corn starch
D&C yellow #10 aluminum lake
FD&C yellow #6 aluminum lake
Hypromellose
Methacrylic acid copolymer
Polysorbate 80
Powdered cellulose
Propylene glycol
Shellac
Sodium lauryl sulfate
Titanium dioxide
Triacetin
May contain talc
Triethyl citrate

not_important - 24-7-2006 at 06:55

Generic non-coated, non-buffered

Active Ingredients
Per Tablet: Aspirin 325 mg
Inactive Ingredients
Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate; Glyceryl Triacetate; Hypromellose; Starch; Talc

In the brand you listed the yellow dyes colour the coating, the iron oxides are in the printing on that. The TiO2 and shellac, and maybe methacrylic polymer, are likely part of the coating.

Cellulose and starch are for bulk and to help set the disintegration properties of the tablet.

When you're using a medicine as a raw material source, try to get generic, uncoated or as simple of a coat as you can find, without printing on the tablet. Generics are cheaper in part because they tend not to have extras in them.

treelike - 4-8-2006 at 11:22

OK, so I got aspirin and started some experimentation today. I don't have a lot of equipment here and could do with some micro-scales so bear with me.

First I needed some way to prove I had made phenol and found out in one of my old chem books that ferric chloride makes a violet colour with phenol. I mixed some ferrous sulphate, from an old chemistry set, with sodium hydroxide and warmed and shook the solution to make a nice brown precipitate of "ferric hydroxide". Then I added a bit of hydrochloric acid to get a cloudy yellow ferric chloride solution (don't ask me why it was cloudy).

Next I tried hydrolysis of aspirin. I put two aspirin tablets with some water in a small test tube with a pellet of sodium hydroxide and heated it. Almost immediately there was a yellow colour around the pellet of NaOH which had fallen to the bottom of the tube.


After some more heating, the solution got mixed up and the yellow colour faded so I guessed it needed a bit more NaOH. After adding another pellet and warming the whole liquid turned dark yellow, almost orange.


I'm not sure where this yellow colour is coming from. The aspirin added ingredients were listed as potato starch, lactose and talc. As far as I know none of them will produce anything yellow with NaOH so it must be from the acetylsalicylic acid itself. Could it be some decomposition product of phenol??

Shortly after this, the solution decided to suddenly spurt over my finger so I swiftly made my way to the sink to wash my hands, hot caustic alkali generally not being a desirable thing to have on your skin. There was no damage done. That'll teach me not to wear gloves.

Fortunately there was enough liquid left in the tube to try it with the Fe2(SO4)3. I got some various interesting colours starting with wine red as shown here:


On washing out the tubes after the expt I could see various other colours including violet and blue. This made me think that I had indeed made phenol- until I read one of the threads above which indicates that salicyclic acid can also make a purple colour with Fe3+

I never really noticed a phenolic smell (not sure if I would even recognise one) but then it occured to me that I should have added a bit of hydrochloric acid because any phenol made was probably locked away as sodium phenoxide due to excess alkali. HCl may have freed up the phenol and made it smell.

I guess the biggest question this experiment has produced for me is what the yellow colour was when the aspirin first reacted with the NaOH.

I think I will re-attempt on a slightly larger scale but perhaps boil away most of the liquid, acidify and hope that a phenol or phenol aqueous solution can be distilled over eventually. Also I'll get a purer ferric solution to test it out.

[Edited on 2007-8-24 by treelike]

not_important - 4-8-2006 at 13:03

The FeCl3 is a more or less generic one for phenols as a family.

Heating complex organics (starch, lactose) with NaOH and air will give you coloured oxidation and condensation product ( 'gorp' ). Plus there are several minor ingredients in even generic plain aspirin, was that an exhaustive list you gave?

The phenol will actually distill out of the dry mix. On this small of a scale, if you incline the tube so the upper section stays cool, maybe wrap a damp cloth around the top, the phenol will condense there.

Check that reference in Vogal, which can be downloaded. You start with the salt of the acid, with the phenolic group free. There needs to be (roughly) the right amount of NaOH to leave half the total Ar-OH free, after some of the NaOH is tied up as carbonate from the CO2 popping off salicyclic acid

NaOH + Ar(OH)(CO2Na) => Na2CO3 + Ar(OH)(H)

BTW - I'd start with a few cc water and the aspirin, no hydroxide. Boil it gentle for a few minutes, you should smell acetic acid. Keep boiling it, adding water as needed, until that smell decreases. Then add the NaOH, and carefully boil it dry, then heat strongly. That way you're not tying much NaOH up with acetic acid, and you'll have a better mix of salicyclate and NaOH.

[edit] I _cannot_ type at all.


[Edited on 5-8-2006 by not_important]

chromium - 4-8-2006 at 13:16

Smell of phenol is very strong and quite different. Some printed circuit boards have slight phenolic smell and some types of watercolors and gouaches in my childhood smelled like phenol. Unfortunately i do not know about modern types.

I converted aspirin to salicylic acid this way: powdered two 500mg tablets of aspirin and added 20ml acetone. This was stirred for some time and filtered. After filtering i got almost (but not completely) clear colorless liquid.

This liquid was evaporated to dryness and NaOH solution was added. (NaOH soln was made beforehand by mixing 10ml distilled water and 1.8g NaOH) Everything dissolved. I heated solution to boiling and then left to cool.

To this liquid i added aproximatele 11ml of 20% HCl. White precipitate immediately formed. This was filtered and dryed. I suppose that resulting white powder was salicylic acid.

I did not prepare phenol from salicylic acid that time although this should be quite easy. One day i mixed very small amount of this salicylic acid with some lime ( Ca(OH)2 ) and heated it strongly in test tube. I did not collect resulting phenol but some of it surely formed as there was very clear smell of phenol.


[Edited on 4-8-2006 by chromium]

treelike - 7-8-2006 at 10:23

Quote:
Originally posted by not_importantHeating complex organics (starch, lactose) with NaOH and air will give you coloured oxidation and condensation product ( 'gorp' ). Plus there are several minor ingredients in even generic plain aspirin, was that an exhaustive list you gave?

That's what I got from the box, whether the list *they* gave was exhaustive I cannot tell :) Maybe for interest's sake I could try NaOH with starch or lactose one day and see if it goes yellow.

Thanks again for the practical suggestions- you guys are really helpful! I'm pretty sure I will get there now. Once I find some mushrooms to test the phenol on I can make a little web page showing colour changes and post it to the general forum.

jimmyboy - 15-8-2006 at 18:06

wouldnt it just be better to put aspirin in sulfuric acid to separate the acetic acid/salicylic -- then boil off the acetic and basify the remains with potassium hydroxide or potassium carbonate - you would end up with potassium sulfate/potassium salicylate - heat them and phenol would form

just wondering

jimmyboy - 17-8-2006 at 01:09

nevermind found my info in this thread


http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=6363

[Edited on 17-8-2006 by jimmyboy]

not_important - 17-8-2006 at 01:17

All he was after is the phenol, so direct base hydrolysis is the shortest, easiest route; it uses fewer reagents. The sodium acetate goes off as methane, so it's not a problem.