Sciencemadness Discussion Board

like button

morganbw - 30-7-2018 at 09:53

It would be nice from my point of view for there to be a like button on each post. It would be a gentle way of giving the poster positive feedback without having to go to the extreme of posting and saying nice with absolutely nothing to add to the thread other than hey guy/gal, thank you for your post.

Corrosive Joeseph - 30-7-2018 at 10:34

NO WAY PLEASE............ THIS IS NOT FACEBOOK

My two cents



/CJ

morganbw - 30-7-2018 at 11:21

Quote: Originally posted by Corrosive Joeseph  
NO WAY PLEASE............ THIS IS NOT FACEBOOK

My two cents



/CJ

having a bad night? I do not even do facebook but if a downvote was available you would have mine.
Let us just let it go and let all of the posts belong to the few new members who are so clueless and confused. Just a note though, your post was a bit corrosive.
This will be my last post in this thread.

Corrosive Joeseph - 30-7-2018 at 11:53

Quote: Originally posted by morganbw  

having a bad night?

Just a note though, your post was a bit corrosive.

This will be my last post in this thread.



Nope, having a great night, but I feel very strongly about this......... :)

Apologies if my post was a bit 'corrosive' (why thank you BTW).

Call me a traditionalist, but if you spend long enough reading the chemistry archives here and elsewhere, you will see that general chit-chat is frowned upon, and if somebody's post is not informative, constructive and 'complimentary' to the rest of the thread, well then, we don't post.

Sorry for being such a forum Nazi, I only gave my opinion.

Please don't let my first post stop you from posting again. If so, I graciously apologise (again).

Let's see what others have to say. It is a public forum after all.



/CJ


[Edited on 30-7-2018 by Corrosive Joeseph]

MJ101 - 30-7-2018 at 12:16

@morganbw: It's a good idea, and it's used on many forums.

However, I think that it would require a major upgrade of the forum software.


No thanks.

Sulaiman - 30-7-2018 at 12:52

If you want to sincerely compliment a members work then copy it and report on your results !
If you sincerely want to criticise a members post(s) then provide references
or copy their work and report on your results :D

Due to members like me there is already excess chit-chat,
I do not want anything that would detract from the art and science of amateur experimentalism.
Whimsy and U2U are available for trivia.

Scientific validity should not be determined by social status.

Some members here are very clever and can be extremely helpful,
but may have a 'delicate' ego,
I would not like a 'Dislike' option for this reason.

[Edited on 30-7-2018 by Sulaiman]

j_sum1 - 30-7-2018 at 13:30

No for two reasons.

It sets up a system where posts are valued (or even ranked) by popularity. This is one of the things that is wrong with the internet and has contributed greatly to the post-truth, fake-news, kardashian/pewdiepie, lowest denominator, clickbait, king of random world that we currently live in. We want content valued according to its merit and not its popularity. Those merits are evident to anyone who takes time to read properly - another thing we value. In summary, a like button rewards the wrong thing.

Secondly, I don't think the board software would support it. And if we are to do changes I would prefer effort go to spam reduction.




@Sulaiman


[/irony]

[Edited on 30-7-2018 by j_sum1]

diddi - 30-7-2018 at 15:12

im glad there is not support for a like button; they really dont reflect much at all imo. on another site a review i wrote has been read 15000+ times (measured by users clicking on the "read more" button), so my first para is interesting enough to elicit a click for more information by many people. so far 2 readers have liked my review.

Herr Haber - 31-7-2018 at 04:04

OOwww !

J_sum1 can I copy/ paste you ?
Or could I clone you if the first is too "world 2.0" :)

I totally agree with all the reasons against given so far.
PLUS: Every single online media with a like / thumbs up or down quickly establishes clans or sides. No reason to divide us more.

DrP - 31-7-2018 at 06:49

Just to play advocate, because no-one else has - I like like and dislike buttons. :-)

I won't bother saying why - but mainly because you can give support to facts and down vote spurious opinions where it is clear. Other reading who might not know what is real and what is BS can see from the opinions of others whether the writing is worth reading or not.

Just my 2 cents. I don't really care either way. :D