Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Acetic anhydride preparation

 Pages:  1  ..  10    12

teodor - 20-3-2025 at 04:55

I'm sorry if this question was already asked, this is quite a long thread. Where can I get the information regarding boiling points of AcOH/Ac2O mixture? If it can be calculated somehow based on physical parameters of each ocompound please enlight me.

Update: already found https://doi.org/10.1021/je60012a004
Thanks who bothered to read my message.

[Edited on 20-3-2025 by teodor]

Waffles SS - 15-4-2025 at 04:26

Quote: Originally posted by Waffles SS  
Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
You are correct, the patent method can work directly with AcOH. But that doesn't lower the reaction temperature of 230-260 C, meaning that you need a pressurized setup. I thought it would be more practical to use benzoic acid at atmospheric pressure for most members.


Thats true.
Monocarboxylic acids with a boiling point of less than 230 degrees do not lead to the formation of anhydride at atmospheric pressure,because below this temperature, mentioned dicarboxylic acid(Phthalic acid) will not lose water and make anhydride itself.

The mechanism of this reaction is interesting for me.
I think each mole of Dicarboxylic acid react with two mole of Monocarboxylic acid and make 1 mole Asymmetric Dicarboxylic anhydride and above 230c 5 members Dicarboxylic anhydride regenerate and lead to formation of carboxylic anhydride.



another interesting patent about synthesis of anhydrides from dicarboxylic anhydride.

Patent suggested Glutaric anhydride but another anhydride tested too.

Attachment: US_2021347722_A1.pdf (1MB)
This file has been downloaded 237 times


clearly_not_atara - 10-5-2025 at 14:36

That sure is a fancy process. Let me see if I understand the approach here.

Normally, if you try to equilibrate acetic acid with glutaric anhydride and distill conventionally, you run into a bad case of Le Chatelier's principle. Acetic acid is the most volatile component, so it boils first, and the equilibrium shift causes more acetic anhydride to decompose. Even if you can make Ac2O, you can't get it out of the reaction mixture efficiently.

Instead, you use flash distillation, as a flow process, which distills the mixture faster than the equilibrium can establish itself. This allows you to separate a fraction containing primarily Ac2O and AcOH and a second fraction containing primarily glutaric acid and its anhydride. These can then be separated by conventional methods. Everything is reused except acetic acid, so the economics are basically optimal.

This is pretty cool, but I don't have any idea how to set up a flash distillation on the tabletop. In principle, it shouldn't be harder than a ketene lamp, and you could definitely make a whole lot of Ac2O if you actually built this thing.

MrDoctor - 10-5-2025 at 22:45

based on what i read, some sort of complex is forming that decomposes to produce a low percentage of anhydride, or perhaps not but, ultimately yielding a low output of anhydride per individual step or batch, and what seems to be important is the use of a vacuum sufficiently hard enough to prevent the acetic anhydride from hydrolyzing, so this follows a similar mechanic that was mentioned at some earlier point in this thread where phosphoric acid of some dehydrated state was suggested, if only one could overcome the issue of the anhydride forming alongside water under conditions that would rapidly cause it to hydrolyze back together before any sort of separation could occur.
read [0046] as well as the example process given right under the table.
the mixture of acetic acid and the glutaric anhydride are heated together for 15 minutes before being distilled under a strong vacuum, i would probably describe this as a flash boil. What isnt clear to me is how long the two need to remain in contact.

I do also have an idea for how one might run this continuously, vaguely. what immediately comes to mind is the idea of putting a chunk of glass frit inside a tube and then melting the tube and clamping it around the frit. using a strong vacuum line if one were to draw up the "transanhydrization" mixture, at say, 100C, it would flow through the frit very slowly, and boil aggressively as it reaches all the way through. furthermore it would be trivial to use a heater of some sort to maintain 100C in the tube itself. the image i thought of was the capillary valve in an air conditioning system, where theres high pressure on one side and low on the other, using a capillary to allow a differential.
If silicone tubing is compatible with acetic acid and the anhydride, you could move the fluid around from reactor to reactor using peristaltic pumps to produce the series of reactions it asks for to get up to 20% or so conversion.

Phosphorus pentoxide dehydration final attempt

greenlight - 18-6-2025 at 03:15

I decided to attempt dehydration of glacial acetic acid with phosphorus pentoxide one more time before putting it to bed for good.

This time I opted to use an inert atmosphere within the reaction flask to exclude as much water vapor as possible in case that was the cause of the tar.

I used 50 ml of glacial acetic acid in a 250ml three neck round bottom flask surrounded by a salt-ice bath with one neck just stoppered for pentoxide addition. The central neck was fitted with an overhead stirrer with PTFE paddle and joint while the third neck had a gas flow adapter hooked up to an argon gas bottle by PVC tubing. The flask was purged of air and stirring started. For ever addition of phosphorus pentoxide, the gas flow was started and the gas inlet opened before opening the first stopper and rapidly deploying two small heaped spatulas of the dehydrating agent. Then the stopper was placed back into the socket before closing the inlet and turning the argon off to ensure an oxygen free environment.

This seemed to be working quite well as only a small amount of gunk was present in the reaction mixture and it only acquired a very pale yellow colour. I don't know how much pentoxide was added as I had no way of weighing it but it was approximately ~50 grams. The temperature was kept low at around 10 degrees the entire time.

After this, argon was not utilised further and the stirrer was swapped out for a liebig condenser. Gentle heat was applied which was increased slowly to a boil from a heating mantle which now caused darkening of the mixture. Reflux was continued for 1 hour whereafter a dark brown reaction mixture now resulted.

An attempt was made to distill and sure enough unreacted glacial acetic acid came off around 117 to 120 degrees C (25 ml) before the temperature started to climb again. Excitement increased as the temperature rose to 130 then to 132 then 134.5 aaaannnddd nothing. Temperature dropped all the way back down to 110 °C and the reaction flask was now foaming tar again.

So, frustratingly, even when babied, this reaction is completely useless.
This one reagent is giving me the hardest time out of any I have had to synthesise and I am seriously considering the ketene lamp after this despite the insane toxicity and fire/explosion hazard if air is in the apparatus.
Oh well, back to the drawing board again it is.



[Edited on 18-6-2025 by greenlight]

Screenshot_20250618_191636_Gallery.jpg - 1.1MB

Fery - 18-6-2025 at 20:40

Hi greenlight, even in case if acetic anhydride was produced it could react with P4O10
https://www.sciencemadness.org/whisper/viewthread.php?tid=15...
P4O10 has also such a problem that if water is produced in a reaction, its surface gets covered with a layer of polyphosphoric acid which prevents further reaction. For the above reaction (acetic anhydride as the reactant and 2,6-dimethyl-gamma-pyrone as a product) I had to dissolve P4O10 in H3PO4 to produce polyphopshoric acid. That polyphosphoric acid was very reactive and my reaction mixture got quickly black color and a lot of tar at the end. You got only pale yellow content in your reaction flask.

greenlight - 20-6-2025 at 09:29

Hello Fery,

Interesting, so your saying that if acetic anhydride is produced, it will undergo further reaction with the phosphorus pentoxide?
Furthermore, even with every effort to exclude any water from the reaction, it can be formed in situ?

clearly_not_atara - 28-6-2025 at 15:02

If you are determined to try a polyphosphoric method I would consider gassing HCl through a solution of NaPO3 in AcOH, assuming that it will actually dissolve. The volatility of AcCl (bp 52 C) might allow it to boil off at lower temperatures where Ac2O would decompose before boiling. But the volatility of AcCl also means that it is more dangerous to handle. Optimal reaction temperature is probably around 50-60 C, but it may be difficult to control. Scrubbing the exhaust will be an issue.

clearly_not_atara - 5-8-2025 at 15:44

And to my great surprise:
https://orgsyn.org/demo.aspx?prep=CV1P0091
Quote:
Benzoic anhydride can be prepared [...] from benzoic acid and phosphorus in benzene solution by shaking with air or oxygen;8
And so it was that the reaction pursued for 15 years and thought impossible turned up in Organic Syntheses of all places, by a completely unexpected methodology.

The citation 8 is: Rankov, Ann. univ. Sofia, II, Faculté phys.-math., Livre 2, 33, 221 (1937) [C. A. 32, 3335 (1938)]. -- this is very hard to track down! It looks like any attempt at this method will require improvisation.

Obviously, benzoic anhydride is not acetic anhydride, but getting the one from the other ought to be pretty simple. It is of course convenient iff you have phosphorus :D

[Edited on 5-8-2025 by clearly_not_atara]

MrDoctor - 6-8-2025 at 15:09

if anyone wanted to try that method listed earlier using dicarboxylic acid anhydrides to dehydrate acetic acid to the anhydride, included in the results were successful instances of using polyphosphoric acid, with similar yields, so, it might be worth trying that process from the patent, aggressively vacuum distilling the mixture after a period of heating/stirring to get seperation.
It occured to me that since acetic anhydrides BP is higher than acid, and this process only produces a small amount each time, maybe the reason rapid vacuum boiling is used is because under high temperatures it reverses moderately quickly? wheras slowly fractionally distilling it would result in it having a huge time spent getting exposed to heat and the hydrated dicarboxylic acid, with a decreasing amount of acetic acid solvating things, so, the reason that during each pass only 2-5% converts is because perhaps thats all steam distills through before it reverses?

So i have a question about that for when i give it a try, is there anything known to azeotrope with acetic anhydride but not acetic acid? or otherwise, anyone know if theres a co-solvent that might help tip the scales to improve how quickly the anhydride can be seperated from the solution so it doesnt hydrolyze again so easily?
the most i could find was azeotropes, for toluene, benzene and cyclohexane, but acetic acid forms an even stronger azeotrope with them so it probably wont help, and toluene was tested in the patent research table. Then theres non-azeotropes, for which all i could find was isopropyl ethers and esters, though i suspect they are the same for acetic acid, similar substances tend to be that way when it comes to just, co-distilling.

Another thing, to anyone having difficulty sourcing glutaric acid to give that patent a try, i didnt save it but there is an inconvenient way to get it from glutamic acid if deaminated a particular way, but also, there is a commercial product known as "dibasic ester", a sometimes cheap solvent, made from the esters of succinic and glutaric acid. otherwise glutaric acid is a rather niche product it seems that is hard to find, even expanding my net internationally i couldnt easily find any for sale outside of scalper-rates, or places selling small amounts of analysis grade stuff asking for $30/g sold by the milligram.

greenlight - 9-8-2025 at 07:17

I just completed a second attempt at the follwing:

1. Benzyl alcohol to benzaldehyde via oxidation with dilute nitric acid.
2. Benzaldehyde to benzoyl chloride by direct chlorination with sulfur catalyst.
3. Benzoyl chloride to acetyl chloride by reaction with glacial acetic acid.

As a test run, 30ml of benzoyl chloride was placed into a 100ml round bottom flask with 20 ml of glacial acetic acid which had been dried by distillation over phosphorus pentoxide. A fractional distillation apparatus was set up with an ice cooled liebig condesner and heat applied from a heating mantle. The recovery was extremely slow with only a drop coming over every minute or so.
The product is definitely acetyl chloride due to still head temp being around 50°C and the distillate fumes acidic vapours upon exposure to air.
The only problem is the yield was only about ~5 ml which corresponds to about 29%.

So, does the reaction of benzoyl chloride and glacial acetic acid produce acetyl chloride? Yes. Is it beneficially viable at the moment? No.

Maybe purifying the benzoyl chloride with further distillation would improve things.

clearly_not_atara - 9-8-2025 at 10:25

Quote:
Another thing, to anyone having difficulty sourcing glutaric acid to give that patent a try, i didnt save it but there is an inconvenient way to get it from glutamic acid if deaminated a particular way, but also, there is a commercial product known as "dibasic ester", a sometimes cheap solvent, made from the esters of succinic and glutaric acid. otherwise glutaric acid is a rather niche product it seems that is hard to find, even expanding my net internationally i couldnt easily find any for sale outside of scalper-rates, or places selling small

I looked into glutaric acid and from all indications it doesn't cyclize as easily as diacids that form 5-membered rings. I wondered if you could just use citric acid to form itaconic and citraconic anhydrides in situ. Otherwise you would need phthalic acid.

The oxidation of alpha-phellandrene in eucalyptus oil should produce 2-isopropylsuccinic acid, which would also be a strong contender as an effective high-boiling catalyst:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phellandrene
It would probably be obtained by oxidizing crude euc. oil and then precipitating the diacid products as their calcium salts. This is still work, unfortunately.

MrDoctor - 9-8-2025 at 23:43

Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
Quote:
Another thing, to anyone having difficulty sourcing glutaric acid to give that patent a try, i didnt save it but there is an inconvenient way to get it from glutamic acid if deaminated a particular way, but also, there is a commercial product known as "dibasic ester", a sometimes cheap solvent, made from the esters of succinic and glutaric acid. otherwise glutaric acid is a rather niche product it seems that is hard to find, even expanding my net internationally i couldnt easily find any for sale outside of scalper-rates, or places selling small

I looked into glutaric acid and from all indications it doesn't cyclize as easily as diacids that form 5-membered rings. I wondered if you could just use citric acid to form itaconic and citraconic anhydrides in situ. Otherwise you would need phthalic acid.

The oxidation of alpha-phellandrene in eucalyptus oil should produce 2-isopropylsuccinic acid, which would also be a strong contender as an effective high-boiling catalyst:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phellandrene
It would probably be obtained by oxidizing crude euc. oil and then precipitating the diacid products as their calcium salts. This is still work, unfortunately.


do you have some sort of source for this idea, that glutaric anhydride cant simply be formed through thermal dehydration? its kind of a central point of the patent that water can just be distilled off and the anhydride regenerated with little effort or the consumption of non-reusable commercial dehydrating agents.

Also, with citric acid, ill look into that. i recently acquired a large, literal lump of glutaric anhydride so ill see how that works out, both, making acetic anhydride but also, how readily it is regenerated. if its not a load of crock, ill try citric acid derivatives because, thats just insanely accessible to anyone with lemon technology.

SHADYCHASE54 - 12-8-2025 at 05:48

Has anyone ever tried reacting red phosphorus with chlorine in glacial acetic acid and distilling off the acetyl chloride? Seems like a potentially simple small scale prep that would give easy access to an acetylating agent. I've never tried it but if you have a good fumehood it should work. Just a thought I probably read it somewhere?

chempyre235 - 12-8-2025 at 06:29

Quote: Originally posted by MrDoctor  
Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
Quote:
Another thing, to anyone having difficulty sourcing glutaric acid to give that patent a try, i didnt save it but there is an inconvenient way to get it from glutamic acid if deaminated a particular way, but also, there is a commercial product known as "dibasic ester", a sometimes cheap solvent, made from the esters of succinic and glutaric acid. otherwise glutaric acid is a rather niche product it seems that is hard to find, even expanding my net internationally i couldnt easily find any for sale outside of scalper-rates, or places selling small

I looked into glutaric acid and from all indications it doesn't cyclize as easily as diacids that form 5-membered rings. I wondered if you could just use citric acid to form itaconic and citraconic anhydrides in situ. Otherwise you would need phthalic acid.

The oxidation of alpha-phellandrene in eucalyptus oil should produce 2-isopropylsuccinic acid, which would also be a strong contender as an effective high-boiling catalyst:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phellandrene
It would probably be obtained by oxidizing crude euc. oil and then precipitating the diacid products as their calcium salts. This is still work, unfortunately.


do you have some sort of source for this idea, that glutaric anhydride cant simply be formed through thermal dehydration? its kind of a central point of the patent that water can just be distilled off and the anhydride regenerated with little effort or the consumption of non-reusable commercial dehydrating agents.

Also, with citric acid, ill look into that. i recently acquired a large, literal lump of glutaric anhydride so ill see how that works out, both, making acetic anhydride but also, how readily it is regenerated. if its not a load of crock, ill try citric acid derivatives because, thats just insanely accessible to anyone with lemon technology.


Citraconic anhydride is the favored product over itaconate in the dry distillation of citric acid. Citraconic anhydride is favored over the free acid, and is a liquid at room temperature. Citric acid begins to decompose to its pyrocitrate derivatives above 175°C.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citric_acid
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citraconic_acid

bnull - 12-8-2025 at 07:48

Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
I looked into glutaric acid and from all indications it doesn't cyclize as easily as diacids that form 5-membered rings.

Fieser & Fieser's Organic Chemistry, 2nd edition, p.312:

20250812_124518.jpg - 191kB

clearly_not_atara - 12-8-2025 at 16:11

Glutaric it is! :D

MrDoctor - 13-8-2025 at 19:09

ill give this a try at some point in the next few weeks or so. Assuming it works, realistically im expecting a yield cap of 5-10% at best in the solution at the end if what it said about re-using the flash-distillate is correct, is there a better way to seperate acetic acid and anhydride than just fractional distillation? or rather, to quickly aproximate the content, when said content is probably 2-3%, in 100ml. i could see this working rather nicely as a continuous or automated process, but as batches, in regular glassware, its going to be a lot of work just to figure out which variables reliably impact the outcome and dial the right settings in. Assuming 20% final concentration is correct, thats not at all unreasonable to just purify by distillation with a little overshoot to be safe and directly produce useable acetic anhydride, but that requires making an assumption, which is that for some reason, the acetic anhydride WONT react as literature says, with glutaric acid, dehydrating it. Patents say all sorts of things and use a rather vague language that makes it hard to tell if the person writing it even understood what the heck they were even doing, which makes someone like me, who also doesnt know what im doing, feel uneasy about sinking a whole weekend into proofing it.

clearly_not_atara - 15-8-2025 at 08:56

Acetic acid, bp 118, forms an azeotrope with toluene, bp 110, which is 72/28 toluene/AcOH (more simply, 5 parts toluene to 2 parts acetic acid) and has a bp of 105 C. This might be helpful, though I'm not certain.

[Edited on 15-8-2025 by clearly_not_atara]

MrDoctor - 17-8-2025 at 01:22

Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
Acetic acid, bp 118, forms an azeotrope with toluene, bp 110, which is 72/28 toluene/AcOH (more simply, 5 parts toluene to 2 parts acetic acid) and has a bp of 105 C. This might be helpful, though I'm not certain.

[Edited on 15-8-2025 by clearly_not_atara]


The idea is to remove the anhydride from the acid so as not to have to distill all the acid every time.
Anyway toluene also forms an azeotrope with acetic anhydride from which the anhydride cannot be seperated at concentrations under 8%
I dont know what the affinity differences are for acetic acid vs toluene for dissolving the anhydride, but either way, including it complicates things and im just talking about a way to quickly determine the yield experimentally, since this system can vary a bit from 2-10% depending on the temperature


That being said i revisited the patent, and noticed entry 26,27,28 "sulfobenzoic" acid/anhydride.
if this is the 2 or ortho kind, that one can obtain by hydrolysis of saccharin by HCl, it should be noted that as opposed to the peak conversion of 16% glutaric anhydride and converting 10% of the acetic acid to anhydride, the sulfobenzoic anhydride seems to dehydrate 30-37% of the acetic acid, hydrating 50-65% to its acid, i am not certain if or not the distillate can be cycled through again, 30% anhydride may be too much and it could just dehydrate the sulfobenzoic acid, wheras glutaric i think is good until spent, but still.

If that sulfobenzoic anhydride is indeed the one easily made from artificial sweetener, im definitely going to try making some and testing it out. As far as i can tell its also infinitely regenerable and doesnt decompose if its not dissolved in water.

Waffles SS - 17-8-2025 at 04:30

One of interesting and easiest method for separation acetic anhydride from acetic acid is chilling to -60 C.
At this temp mixture solidified and by heating gradually anhydride separate easily. (melting point of anhydride is lower than acetic acid)
I did this method by dry ice many times and reach more than 85% purity of anhydride by repeating this procedure three times.

MrDoctor - 17-8-2025 at 15:11

Quote: Originally posted by Waffles SS  
One of interesting and easiest method for separation acetic anhydride from acetic acid is chilling to -60 C.
At this temp mixture solidified and by heating gradually anhydride separate easily. (melting point of anhydride is lower than acetic acid)
I did this method by dry ice many times and reach more than 85% purity of anhydride by repeating this procedure three times.


that is certainly interesting. it makes me wonder if adding an immiscible solvent would then push all the anhydride into that solvent, some reactions push on like that because if the anhydride has somewhere to go, though i think the force there tends to be the potential in the phase change and that usually is favored in the other direction, but anyway, that might allow the acetic acid to begin freezing at much lower temps if the anhydride is whats keeping the acid from crystalizing and thus concentrating the anhydride further, but this assumes that from the get go that the solvent in question is at least somewhat effective at pulling anhydride out, and on top of that either also doesnt form an azeotrope, or, would be extracted very quick and easily to a high degree of efficiency in this case, because then what could be done is, the starting and finish weight could be measured to see how much weight change occured in either the acid or the solvent after extraction.

Waffles SS - 18-8-2025 at 04:18

Quote: Originally posted by MrDoctor  


that is certainly interesting. it makes me wonder if adding an immiscible solvent would then push all the anhydride into that solvent, some reactions push on like that because if the anhydride has somewhere to go, though i think the force there tends to be the potential in the phase change and that usually is favored in the other direction, but anyway, that might allow the acetic acid to begin freezing at much lower temps if the anhydride is whats keeping the acid from crystalizing and thus concentrating the anhydride further, but this assumes that from the get go that the solvent in question is at least somewhat effective at pulling anhydride out, and on top of that either also doesnt form an azeotrope, or, would be extracted very quick and easily to a high degree of efficiency in this case, because then what could be done is, the starting and finish weight could be measured to see how much weight change occured in either the acid or the solvent after extraction.


Related patent.


Attachment: US1941951.pdf (347kB)
This file has been downloaded 113 times

[Edited on 18-8-2025 by Waffles SS]

MrDoctor - 18-8-2025 at 04:47

damn, if i read that patent right it seems like nothing useful can be done until -40C at best, even with what i was saying, although i think they only tested solvents that dissolve both the acid and the anhydride and only with respects to keeping water out. but it means if there is such a solvent, its not those.
Maybe at some point though ill give something a try, and see what happens if i mix -20C thoroughly frozen but crushed up, glacial acetic acid, with a -20C mixture of acid/anhydride, then put them together in the freezer and see what happens when additional solvents are introduced, if perhaps the existence of already solid acetic acid helps things along, since less energy is needed to precipitate onto an existing solid of that kind than to do so spontaneously from liquid

Waffles SS - 18-8-2025 at 10:38

Quote: Originally posted by MrDoctor  
damn, if i read that patent right it seems like nothing useful can be done until -40C at best, even with what i was saying, although i think they only tested solvents that dissolve both the acid and the anhydride and only with respects to keeping water out. but it means if there is such a solvent, its not those.
Maybe at some point though ill give something a try, and see what happens if i mix -20C thoroughly frozen but crushed up, glacial acetic acid, with a -20C mixture of acid/anhydride, then put them together in the freezer and see what happens when additional solvents are introduced, if perhaps the existence of already solid acetic acid helps things along, since less energy is needed to precipitate onto an existing solid of that kind than to do so spontaneously from liquid

If you have access to dry ice then lowering temp is not difficult (dry ice temp is ~-70c)
Also preparing dry ice is simple if you have CO2 gas cylinder

Anyway I want to introduce another interesting method for synthesis carboxylic acid anhydride by electrolysis.

Electrolysis by graphite anode and steel cathode of mixture:
Carboxylic acid + acetonitrile + catalyst (potassium thiocyanate) make anhydride


Attachment: 10.1002@open.202200059.pdf (1.6MB)
This file has been downloaded 145 times

Attachment: open202200059-sup-0001-misc_information.pdf (3.2MB)
This file has been downloaded 140 times


[Edited on 18-8-2025 by Waffles SS]

MrDoctor - 18-8-2025 at 20:14

Quote: Originally posted by Waffles SS  

Anyway I want to introduce another interesting method for synthesis carboxylic acid anhydride by electrolysis.

Electrolysis by graphite anode and steel cathode of mixture:
Carboxylic acid + acetonitrile + catalyst (potassium thiocyanate) make anhydride
[Edited on 18-8-2025 by Waffles SS]


I would have eaten my desk out of pure rage, had that paper been published in like 1970 or something and yet again such a valuable piece of research had been sat on for 50 years before we (amateur chemists) found out about it. But luckily it was published in 2022, so my desk remains largely bite free.

I am currently in possession of some tetrabutylammonium bromide, and can easily concentrate my 90% weed killer grade acetic acid to glacial for the occasion. I think i will try this and report back, though, since the tetraethylhalide electrolytes yielded nothing at all, i wonder if maybe i need to change out the bromide for something else?
Im not particularly comfortable with trying to synthesize thiocyanate, since there doesnt really seem to be a way around it without using cyanide, and i dont understand its chemistry at all and see that it can potentially hydrolyze back to cyanide, and, if the cost is just efficiency or anode lifespan, then i already have what i need right now.
now that being said, i also have a bit of a silly postulation, since potassium cyanate was shown to work, but not tested on graphite, just boron doped diamond which performed universally worse than graphite. what if i stuck cyanate onto TBA? potassium cyanate performed terrible, but it did perform, also these results were all from butyric anhydride formation not acetic, so idk how that translates, and if even the values are a yield cap since all tests were done with 1.1F, not run all the way to determine where they top out, aside from a general statement that 70% is as high as it goes

clearly_not_atara - 19-8-2025 at 05:14

Ha, what an amazing method to end up on the end of a page. Nice find, Waffles.

Waffles SS - 19-8-2025 at 06:18

Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
Ha, what an amazing method to end up on the end of a page. Nice find, Waffles.

Thanks,
I also know better and more exciting method for synthesis Ac2O!
Do you have access to vinyl acetate or acetylene gas?are you ready for introduce another interesting method?(my favorite method )

chempyre235 - 19-8-2025 at 06:39

Not sure what country you live in, but Scientific Polymer has vinyl acetate for 8-10 cents/gram, depending on the quantity purchased.

Waffles SS - 19-8-2025 at 11:16

Quote: Originally posted by chempyre235  
Not sure what country you live in, but Scientific Polymer has vinyl acetate for 8-10 cents/gram, depending on the quantity purchased.

Here the price of VA monomer is 2$ per kg

chempyre235 - 19-8-2025 at 11:30

Who sells it? If they're US, I might add to my list of suppliers.

Waffles SS - 19-8-2025 at 17:30

Quote: Originally posted by chempyre235  
Who sells it? If they're US, I might add to my list of suppliers.


My Vinyl acetate monomer made by Shazand Petrochemical Company

[Edited on 20-8-2025 by Waffles SS]

MrDoctor - 6-11-2025 at 00:15

i have noticed here and there occasionally its mentioned acetic anhydride decomposes when boiled/distilled, could someone elaborate on this? im currently distilling an AcOH/Ac2O mixture of unknown concentration and its kind of stuck at 123-125C, afaik the acid content should be dropping it shouldnt be forming a stable constant boiling mixture, but it does have me concerned its somehow decomposing.


clearly_not_atara - 6-11-2025 at 19:06

I think there are other ways to separate them, like by crystallization. You could chill and mix with a light alkane or similar np. AcOH will ppt.

MrDoctor - 7-11-2025 at 03:17

it looks like ill have to try that. i think i finally managed to prepare a modest quantity of pure acetic anhydride to deliberately dilute and test the feasibility of seperation from the acid. as for the odd behaviour i noted earlier, i believe thats just because where the curves meet in the middle, a certain mixture of acid/anhydride is favored so it hangs around 125C for a long time.

I really want to see if its possible to isolate the acetic anhydride from around 500ml of 20% anhydride in acid. its the upper end of what glutaric anhydride will get, or pessimistically what sulfobenzoic anhydride (made from saccharine) will get, and similarly, the lower end of what electrolysis with thiocyanate in acetonitrile will give.

While on the subject, i dont recall if i read this in literature or if grok spewed it to me, but is there perhaps a salt that can be used to brine-out the anhydride? the one recommended to me was anhydrous magnesium chloride. it seems logical that if you had a salt soluble in acetic acid and specifically NOT soluble in acetic anhydride, that some amount would cause layering to occur. Or similarly allow for efficient seperation of acetic acid/anydride from toluene since the 3 are miscible and form a ternary azeotrope of sorts.


Alkoholvergiftung - 7-11-2025 at 09:32

Why do you have an acid mix? Did you use the thermal cracking methode of glacial acetic acid. coincidence i searched patents of acetic acid anhydrid and i found some patents on cracking glacial acetic acid vaposrs on silica gel catalyst at 700C and they wrote an yield of 54% anhydrid and the rest is glacial acetic acid. If used80% acetic acid temperature for the cracking is 750C and yield is only 48%. Also an mix with acetic acid. If you can separet them without problems maybe an interesting methode of making AcO.

bnull - 7-11-2025 at 10:19

Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara  
I think there are other ways to separate them, like by crystallization. You could chill and mix with a light alkane or similar np. AcOH will ppt.

This, I believe:
Attachment: US1941951.pdf (347kB)
This file has been downloaded 81 times

Waffles SS - 13-11-2025 at 23:31

Quote: Originally posted by MrDoctor  
it looks like ill have to try that. i think i finally managed to prepare a modest quantity of pure acetic anhydride to deliberately dilute and test the feasibility of seperation from the acid. as for the odd behaviour i noted earlier, i believe thats just because where the curves meet in the middle, a certain mixture of acid/anhydride is favored so it hangs around 125C for a long time.

I really want to see if its possible to isolate the acetic anhydride from around 500ml of 20% anhydride in acid. its the upper end of what glutaric anhydride will get, or pessimistically what sulfobenzoic anhydride (made from saccharine) will get, and similarly, the lower end of what electrolysis with thiocyanate in acetonitrile will give.

While on the subject, i dont recall if i read this in literature or if grok spewed it to me, but is there perhaps a salt that can be used to brine-out the anhydride? the one recommended to me was anhydrous magnesium chloride. it seems logical that if you had a salt soluble in acetic acid and specifically NOT soluble in acetic anhydride, that some amount would cause layering to occur. Or similarly allow for efficient seperation of acetic acid/anydride from toluene since the 3 are miscible and form a ternary azeotrope of sorts.


I was successful in separation of Ac2O from AcOH by fraction distallation but you should have good column and repeat it tree times at last but if you can provide <-50c then separation will be easier(i reach this temp by homemade dry ice).

If you are serious in making AC2O i suggest Vinyl acetate route (or better isopropenyl acetate) that is easier and good yield method.

[Edited on 14-11-2025 by Waffles SS]

MrDoctor - 14-11-2025 at 01:44

Quote: Originally posted by Waffles SS  


If you are serious in making AC2O i suggest Vinyl acetate route (or better isopropenyl acetate) that is easier and good yield method.

[Edited on 14-11-2025 by Waffles SS]


How is that done? i tried searching it up but all i found was you saying you tried a certain reaction and it didnt work. Or did you mean indirectly using it as an acetaldehyde source?
Ultimately i wound up getting some pure acetic anhydride but im curious as to what method could be used.

also turns out what i was distilling in the 120s was just a contaminant, distilling these mixtures seems not too unlike distilling ethanol and is vastly simpler to make pure if the starting conc is high, so instead im just going to test out some methods of salt/brining the anhydride out, one thing i never considered either was the possibility of just saturating the acid with glutaric anhydride and seeing what happens when i have a known quantity of anhydride present, and not presumed based on a patent.


Waffles SS - 14-11-2025 at 01:53

Quote: Originally posted by MrDoctor  


How is that done? i tried searching it up but all i found was you saying you tried a certain reaction and it didnt work. Or did you mean indirectly using it as an acetaldehyde source?


VA +ACOH -catalyst->acetaldehyde +Ac2O
Search this topic .(i posted details before.)


Quote:

Example 7
In a copper kettle with an attached fractionation column, a mixture of 860 parts vinyl acetate, 600 parts acetic acid, 1.0 part sulfuric acid, and 2.0 parts phosphoric acid was boiled. The resulting aldehyde was distilled off in a nitrogen stream of 20 volume units per hour. The distillation of the aldehyde proceeded more smoothly than without a gas stream. The residue remaining in the kettle contained 75% acetic anhydride, which, during fractionation under vacuum, was largely obtained directly as a 98% pure product. The material yield was almost quantitative. The resin produced amounted to only 0.37% of the feedstock.

DE503131


Attachment: DE503131C.pdf (244kB)
This file has been downloaded 68 times

photo_2025-08-11_17-11-20.jpg - 76kB

This is my setup for this reaction and separation(there are glass marble in column )


[Edited on 14-11-2025 by Waffles SS]

Radiums Lab - 14-11-2025 at 03:11

Ketene can be prepared by heting CH3COOH in Fe tubes. I know ketene is toxic but...

Alkoholvergiftung - 14-11-2025 at 04:46

waffle ss i ve found an swiss patent where they use acetaldehyd and glacial acetic acid whith an cobalt or copperacetat catalyst. It forms acetic anhydride too. Maybe so you can use your acetaldehyd waste. :D

Attachment: AcO.Acetaldehyd_all_pages.pdf (140kB)
This file has been downloaded 66 times


Waffles SS - 14-11-2025 at 08:13

Quote: Originally posted by Alkoholvergiftung  
waffle ss i ve found an swiss patent where they use acetaldehyd and glacial acetic acid whith an cobalt or copperacetat catalyst. It forms acetic anhydride too. Maybe so you can use your acetaldehyd waste. :D

Acetic anhydride from acetaldehyde and cobalt catalyst mentioned before in this topic.

This method is not feasible and need special equipment that is not available for most of amateur chemists.

There are interesting methods for synthesis acetic anhydride, but this method is not one of them.

Do you want I introduce one of that interesting method?


[Edited on 14-11-2025 by Waffles SS]

Alkoholvergiftung - 14-11-2025 at 09:29

Yes Sensei, teach. Only found the direct methode of 8mol of Sodiumacetat 1
mol sulfur and than chlorine. So no sulfurdichloride must be made.

Waffles SS - 14-11-2025 at 09:55

One of easiest and fastest method for synthesis Ac2O is Dehydrating AcOH by DCC(N,N'-Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide)

Add acetic acid to same volume of dichloromethane and then add calculated amount of DCC,Stir for 30 minutes at 30-40c filter insoluble material and evaporate solvent and done,You will get good yield of Ac2O.

DCC is available in most of organic lab and i think is not illegal in your country (but careful about toxicity )



[Edited on 14-11-2025 by Waffles SS]

MaeBorowski - 25-12-2025 at 08:29

Two old Soviet patents claim that AA can be made from acetamide, acetic acid, and a strong acid (H2SO4 or HCl in these cases).

SU17216: 2AcNH2 + 2AcOH + H2SO4 = 2Ac2O + (NH4)2SO4
A mixture of acetic acid, acetamide, and sulfuric acid taken in the corresponding ratio (2:2:1 moles) is heated in a flask, and the forming AA is distilled off with a Vigreux column. The distillate is purified by fractional distillation, yielding a product containing 85 to 93% of AA (that's not the yield!!).
SU19625: AcNH2 + AcOH + HCl = Ac2O + NH4Cl
Hydrogen chloride is passed into a mixture of acetamide and glacial acetic acid (1:1 moles). The formed acetic anhydride is distilled with a Vigreux column. The fraction boiling between 130 and 142 C is redistilled, giving a product with up to 96% AA (again, it's not the yield. the patent doesn't say anything about the temperature that should be maintained during the saturation, but it could get pretty hot without external cooling)

Waffles SS - 25-12-2025 at 10:04

Quote: Originally posted by MaeBorowski  
Two old Soviet patents claim that AA can be made from acetamide, acetic acid, and a strong acid (H2SO4 or HCl in these cases).

SU17216: 2AcNH2 + 2AcOH + H2SO4 = 2Ac2O + (NH4)2SO4
A mixture of acetic acid, acetamide, and sulfuric acid taken in the corresponding ratio (2:2:1 moles) is heated in a flask, and the forming AA is distilled off with a Vigreux column. The distillate is purified by fractional distillation, yielding a product containing 85 to 93% of AA (that's not the yield!!).
SU19625: AcNH2 + AcOH + HCl = Ac2O + NH4Cl
Hydrogen chloride is passed into a mixture of acetamide and glacial acetic acid (1:1 moles). The formed acetic anhydride is distilled with a Vigreux column. The fraction boiling between 130 and 142 C is redistilled, giving a product with up to 96% AA (again, it's not the yield. the patent doesn't say anything about the temperature that should be maintained during the saturation, but it could get pretty hot without external cooling)


Many years ago i tried this method and i have to say another bullshit method.

dont waste your time and money !

MaeBorowski - 26-12-2025 at 07:12

It appeared quite obscure and hadn't been mentioned here, or at least I wasn't able to find any methods involving acetamide :( Sorry for relaying false data.

Do you remember any details of your experiments?

Waffles SS - 27-12-2025 at 10:51

Quote: Originally posted by MaeBorowski  


Do you remember any details of your experiments?

I did this experiment 10 years ago and i dont remember details.but i remember this patent was/is bullshit.

Alkoholvergiftung - 28-12-2025 at 05:57

Waffles. Could Polyvinylacetat also be used? It is sold as Glue it could be bought in 5l containers.

[Edited on 28-12-2025 by Alkoholvergiftung]

Waffles SS - 28-12-2025 at 22:08

Quote: Originally posted by Alkoholvergiftung  
Waffles. Could Polyvinylacetat also be used? It is sold as Glue it could be bought in 5l containers.



No,
Actually you need the monomer, not the polymer. There is a double bond on the monomer which reacts with acetic acid to produce acetal (ethylidene diacetate).

marvinjs-output(1).jpeg - 19kB

If you have access to the starting materials, there are simpler methods for synthesizing Ac2O (than the VA method).

Another simple method is to react Tosyl chloride with dry sodium acetate. Do you have access to them?


marvinjs-output(3).jpeg - 15kB


[Edited on 29-12-2025 by Waffles SS]

 Pages:  1  ..  10    12