Sciencemadness Discussion Board

synthesis of formaldehyde?

thereelstory - 19-1-2010 at 20:50

could someone please give me some insight on how to prepare this?

Panache - 19-1-2010 at 21:17

Heat some pure copper wire til red heat, quench into a beaker of methanol. With each quenching some formaldehyde is produced, keep repeating until it is at desired concentration, may require cooling. Otherwise heat a section of copper tube til red, run methanol vapour through, significant fire and poisoning risk.

I may know your brother, the unrealstory. Funny joke, Ha!

[Edited on 20-1-2010 by Panache]

medchem - 19-1-2010 at 21:22

you can try catalytic (silver) oxidation of methanol

following paper has included other methods too, plz refer to it.....

Applied Catalysis A: General
Volume 238, Issue 2, 20 January 2003, Pages 211-222

good luck

bbartlog - 19-1-2010 at 21:47

Pyrolysis of formate salts (for example calcium or zinc) will give some formaldehyde, but I believe yields are poor.

kilowatt - 19-1-2010 at 21:49

You can decompose trioxane fuel tablets with sulfuric acid as a catalyst; trioxane is a trimer of formaldehyde and is broken down under strongly acidic conditions. The fuel tablets can be gotten for very cheap as military surplus, however they have a waxy binder which inhibits the reaction making it a somewhat slow process. It would be ideal if this could be separated but I have not had much success doing that.

entropy51 - 20-1-2010 at 06:32

Quote: Originally posted by S.C. Wack  
PREPARATION OF FORMALDEHYDE

In the usual way.

See original post for attachment here

Saw the name H. Adkins in Blazter's document and figured that this is a non-bullshit patent.

US19330613

[Edited on 2-8-2009 by S.C. Wack]

bbartlog - 20-1-2010 at 07:52

Now, *that* is a patent. If all patents contained that level of detail and restricted themselves to such a narrow range of claims, I'd be a lot more enthusiastic about our IP system. Instead most patents I see now (specifically relating to catalysts) try to define some huge space of compounds (XaYbZc where X is a group blahblahblah metal and Z is one of O, S, or SO4 and a b c are in the range of 0.1 to 2.7 and etc...), such that it's clear that the applicant can't possibly have thoroughly explored the space and is just trying to stake a claim.

[Edited on 20-1-2010 by bbartlog]

franklyn - 6-3-2010 at 12:13

There has been continued interest here in production of Formaldehyde

http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=132
http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=525
http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=5993

The established method of production is by partial oxidation of Methanol vapor
in air against a silver catalyst at 450 - 650 ºC , yielding formalin
2 CH3OH + O2 => 2 CH2O + 2 H2O , containing unreacted methanol.

The following known pathways suggest another method of preparative value.
An electric arc passed between carbon electrodes under water consumes
the electrodes C + H2O => CO + H2 forming water gas.
A mixture of CO + H2 under the action of dark (silent) electric discharge
yields formaldehyde => CH2O
The first process has been known a long time , it's mentioned on page 485
as a Preparation of Carbon Monoxide in
" A Treatise on General and Industrial Inorganic Chemistry " 1920
http://books.google.com/books/download/Treatise_on_general_a...
More recently rediscovered as a means of coal gasification , the important thing
is not the claims made by the promoter , but that the production of CO + H2 is
plentiful and abundant depending only on the amount of electric power consumed.
http://www.blazelabs.com/n-aquagen.asp
http://www.blazelabs.com/n-newfuel.asp

The next process combining CO + H2 into Formaldehyde is somewhat obscure.
It is simply an ozonizer aparatus which is instead infused with CO and H2.
Seemingly , no one realized the water gas process complements co-generation.
This is difficult to make right , results are mixed , only some have seen success.
Interaction of Carbon Monoxide and Hydrogen Under Silent Discharge:
Production of Formaldehyde
- http://www.springerlink.com/content/q2k5754wk726t676
http://resources.metapress.com/pdf-preview.axd?code=q2k5754w...
http://www.fischer-tropsch.org/Bureau_of_Mines/abs_of_lit/li...
http://www.fischer-tropsch.org/Bureau_of_Mines/abs_of_lit/li...
http://www.fischer-tropsch.org/Bureau_of_Mines/abs_of_lit/li...
Losanitsch and Jovitschitsch , Ber., (1897) 30, pg 135
Löb , Z. Elektrochem., (1906) 12, pg 282
Koenig and Weinig _ http://www.fischer-tropsch.org/Bureau_of_Mines/abs_of_lit/li...


A basic setup would be a carbon rod greased with vaseline to make it electrically
insulated , standing in the open end of a metal can in proximity to perhaps 40 cm
of granular metalurgical coke in the bottom , submerged in a half liter of water. This
can stands inside another canister filled with water running into it to provide cooling.
The can is grounded corresponding to the electric socket ground and the carbon rod
is the hot wire. Electric power is regulated by a small choke in series with the circuit.
A cutoff plastic soda bottle top fits over the inside can so that it is air tight. The
opening runs the gas produced into a chilled reflux column intended to stop water
vapor. The gas is further dried by passing through a container of Calcium Chloride
" ice melt salt ".
The dry gas now enters the " ozonizer " to be converted into Formaldehyde , from
there directly absorbed into a receiver holding perhaps a liter of chilled water. The
entire device will have been initially purged of all air containing only water gas. As
the Formaldehyde formed is continuously dissolved providing a partial vacuum , the
positive pressure of the water gas formed drives the flow toward the reciever. The
beauty of this is that no metering of the CO , H2 gas is required since it is produced
quantitatively in the exact proportion necessary at the source. The gas flow must
be turbulent to prevent separation , as Hydrogen is less dense than CO.

If one wants to produce hexamine directly , the receiving liquor can contain a
solution of Ammonium Sulfate , which should precipitate Hexamine di-sulfate.

Important - Carbon monoxide being an odorless poison gas requires a detector
of it's presence be close to the setup when it's run to warn of any leak. These
are available in hardware stores for around 50 - 60 dollars. Failure to take this
prcaution means you may never wake up.

.

Eclectic - 6-3-2010 at 16:00

I've had great success in separating pure trioxane from fuel tablets. Fill bottom 1/4 of 5 gallon plastic bucket with them, snap on lid, and leave them on a small low power heating pad, such as is used for seed germination or terrarium heating. Pure Trioxane will sublimate and crystallize on the upper sides and top of the bucket over about a 2 week period. :D

You can also melt them and strain out the wax for initial purification, but it's messy and odorous.

[Edited on 3-7-2010 by Eclectic]

chief - 7-3-2010 at 02:09

Just theoretically: Since "al-dehyd" means "alcoholus dehydratus", i.e. dehydrated alcohol:
==> Can't just the Alcohol (Methanol) be dehydrated ?

Maybe it can't for some reason, just sharing ...

turd - 7-3-2010 at 02:33

CH3OH - H2O --> CH2 (carbene)
CH3OH - H2 --> HCHO (formaldehyde)

ITYM dehydrogenation and not dehydration.
In any case, paraformaldehyde is trivially depolymerized to formaldehyde and the former should be available practically everywhere.

I was asked to sketch the apparatus I proposed above

franklyn - 6-4-2011 at 22:22

CH2O by electrical means.gif - 17kB

franklyn - 6-4-2011 at 22:27

An electrolytic process to make formaldehyde is disclosed in this
abstract , the product is essentially commercial strength formalin.
Translated below, restating the preceding brief summary is the
excerpt from the cited German Patent Attachment: DE138442.pdf (251kB)
This file has been downloaded 814 times
Electrolytic Prep of alcohols , aldehydes & ketones.gif - 61kB

Beispiel V.
Für die Bildung von Aldehyden mag nachstehendes Beispiel zur Erläuterung dienen:
Als Elektrolyt dient eine Lösung, die in 500 ccm Flüssigkeit ca. 120 g Natriumacetat
und 160 g Natriumchlorat enthält. Die Elektroden bestehen aus Platinblech, die
Stromdichte ist ca. 20 bis 30 Amp. pro Quadratdecimeter, die Temperatur ca.
20 bis 30° C. Die Isolierung geschieht wie bereits beschrieben.
Man erhält bei diesem Versuch wesentlich Formaldehyd.
Die Ausbeute an Formaldehyd und Methylalkohol beträgt etwa 60 pCt. der Theorie,
wobei beide Körper etwa im Verhältnis 2 : 1 sich gebildet hatten.

Example V.
For the formation of aldehydes the following example may serve for explanation:
A solution of 500 cubic centimetres serves as an electrolyte, containing approximately
120 gms of sodium acetate and 160 gms sodium chlorate. The electrodes are of platinum metal,
Current density is approximately 20 to 30 amperes per square decimeter, the temperature
approximately 20 to 30 °C. Isolation is as already described.
One receives with this attempt substantial formaldehyde.
The yield in formaldehyde and methyl alcohol amounts to about 60 percent of the theory,
both form possibly in the proportion 2 : 1

.

questions - 7-4-2011 at 21:21

I just thought of an idea, please if anyone has any thoughts, please tell me what you think.

I add the right amount of Hcl to hexamine in a thick HDPE container so it will break the hexamine down to a solution of water, formaldehyde and ammonium chloride. I then put in lead electrodes and begin passing electricity through the solution. I then put an air tight lid over the top of the solution and use a vacuum pump to suck all the air out of the container. This will cause the formaldehyde to boil out and into a receiver container with ice and chilled water to collect it.
I'm guessing that the ammonium and chlorine ions wont disstill over with the formaldehyde as they would still be bound to the electrodes as electricity would still be passing through it.

Do you think this would work in my attempt to separate the ammonium chloride from the formaldehyde solution ?

Panache - 8-4-2011 at 00:04

Quote: Originally posted by questions  
I just thought of an idea, please if anyone has any thoughts, please tell me what you think.

I add the right amount of Hcl to hexamine in a thick HDPE container so it will break the hexamine down to a solution of water, formaldehyde and ammonium chloride. I then put in lead electrodes and begin passing electricity through the solution. I then put an air tight lid over the top of the solution and use a vacuum pump to suck all the air out of the container. This will cause the formaldehyde to boil out and into a receiver container with ice and chilled water to collect it.
I'm guessing that the ammonium and chlorine ions wont disstill over with the formaldehyde as they would still be bound to the electrodes as electricity would still be passing through it.

Do you think this would work in my attempt to separate the ammonium chloride from the formaldehyde solution ?


Formaldehyde is quite a poison and i think given your question, which although imaginative shows significant inexperience and less knowledge, that you best develop your skills with something more benign, begin perhaps with distilling water and ammonium chloride to see some of the properties of the chemicals you want to play with.
In short, and i intend no patronization, what you propose is quite dangerous and will not work as you describe.

ScienceSquirrel - 8-4-2011 at 03:31

I seem to remember that electrolysing a solution of ammonium chloride is one of the ways that you can make nitrogen trichloride.
Fascinating stuff, it's most notable property is that it explodes at the slightest provocation.

questions - 8-4-2011 at 05:57

I am trying to make formaldehyde. When I add Hcl to hexamine, it turns into a solution of formaldehyde, water and ammonium chloride. Adding Hcl to hexamine is a great way to get formaldehyde but I want to get rid of that that ammonium chloride that also forms, does anyone have any ideas as to how I can somehow remove the ammonium chloride out of the solution?

ScienceSquirrel - 8-4-2011 at 07:24

Why not buy some formadehyde?
It is readily available for treating diseases in Koi carp where I live. The local aquarium shop will sell you a litre without batting an eyelid :)

formaldehyde

questions - 9-4-2011 at 00:26

Here in australia the most we can buy from an aquarium is a 3.7% solution. It is just too dilute :(

azo - 9-4-2011 at 04:16

just go to a farming warehouse and buy sheep dip that is 37% formaldehyde nothing else.

formaldehyde

questions - 9-4-2011 at 05:28

I have found that alot of farming supply companies don't sell it anymore as they are starting to say that there as other substituteswhich are as good and less dangerous to humans.

Ephoton - 11-4-2011 at 18:32

id be looking into the neff reaction with nitromethane.

I belive it would make for some pritty pure formaldehyde :)

might be a bit pricey but thats never stopped me.

the problem you will get with using hexamine is the formation of methylamine from
imine formation between formaldehyde and ammonium chloride.

with the neff this will not happen.

still I would be using dilute sulfuric acid to work with the nitro salt.
this way when you distill you dont get HCl comming over as well.

make sure you dont use too much acid or you will polymerise the aldehyde.

[Edited on 12-4-2011 by Ephoton]

Panache - 13-4-2011 at 02:57

camping stores in australia sell a 22% solution in one and two litre bottles as 'porta loo treatment'. Problem is when you smell it you just want to go to a festival.

azo - 13-4-2011 at 03:53

Be carefull thinking that portable toilet fluid has formaldehyde in it, this is not the prefured compound these days because of the toxic properties of formaldehyde.
glutaraldehyde is more used because it controls odours better than quaternary ammonium compounds.


regards azo

[Edited on 13-4-2011 by azo]

Panache - 13-4-2011 at 15:48

Quote: Originally posted by azo  
Be carefull thinking that portable toilet fluid has formaldehyde in it, this is not the prefured compound these days because of the toxic properties of formaldehyde. is more used because it controls odours better than quaternary ammonium compounds.


regards azo

[Edited on 13-4-2011 by azo]


Really, thats interesting, i might get some now and see, its (formaldehyde) is a schedule 7 poison since 2003 in australia and you're right using it for anything i a regulatory headache. i know within the food industry its simply impossible and not worth the trouble, even for plant washdown during shutdown.

azo - 13-4-2011 at 23:32

The maufactures push it as a less toxic alternative but i don't agree with that .I think they are both as bad as each other,the glutaraldehyde does not exist as a free aldehyde but as a pentahydrate.



regards azo

safety first - 27-3-2012 at 11:26

What about the hydrolysis of dimethoxymethane (methylal) in aqueous acid? I believe methylal can be found as the European substitute of DCM in paint strippers. It also comes in those electronics cleaning sprays if I'm not mistaken. According to wiki it hydrolyzes back to formaldehyde and methanol in the presence of the acid.

Just bought a can of paint stripper and planning to try this weekend. It shouldn't be very hard I'll just try to find a patent of sorts..

weiming1998 - 29-3-2012 at 00:39

What's with all those complex tube setups? Oxidation of methanol with KMnO4 will do. Traces of formic acid will be formed, but not much, if you control the amount of KMnO4 you put in. If your experiment won't allow any formic acid, then neutralize with a suitable hydroxide/carbonate that forms a formate salt that's not very soluble. Then freeze and filter. Formaldehyde is more soluble in cold water than hot, while the solids are generally more soluble in hot water than cold.

Lambda-Eyde - 29-3-2012 at 06:08

Quote: Originally posted by weiming1998  
What's with all those complex tube setups? Oxidation of methanol with KMnO4 will do. Traces of formic acid will be formed, but not much, if you control the amount of KMnO4 you put in. If your experiment won't allow any formic acid, then neutralize with a suitable hydroxide/carbonate that forms a formate salt that's not very soluble.

Have you tried this method of yours and analyzed the product? Do you have any references for this reaction?

weiming1998 - 29-3-2012 at 06:34

Quote: Originally posted by Lambda-Eyde  
Quote: Originally posted by weiming1998  
What's with all those complex tube setups? Oxidation of methanol with KMnO4 will do. Traces of formic acid will be formed, but not much, if you control the amount of KMnO4 you put in. If your experiment won't allow any formic acid, then neutralize with a suitable hydroxide/carbonate that forms a formate salt that's not very soluble.

Have you tried this method of yours and analyzed the product? Do you have any references for this reaction?


I have, just on the oxidation of ethanol instead of methanol, and since the two alcohols/aldehydes are very similar, it should work for methanol as well. I haven't done any proper analysis based on testing solutions, but the smell of the acetaldehyde, the bubbling of the solution and the fact that the smell isn't cleared by the addition of a base confirms the fact that it is an aldehyde.

References? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_oxidation
The end product of the oxidation is a carboxylic acid, but you see, the aldehyde is an intermediate product. If you use an excess of the alcohol, more aldehydes are going to be produced instead of carboxylic acids.

Lambda-Eyde - 29-3-2012 at 07:06

Quote: Originally posted by weiming1998  

I have, just on the oxidation of ethanol instead of methanol, and since the two alcohols/aldehydes are very similar, it should work for methanol as well. I haven't done any proper analysis based on testing solutions, but the smell of the acetaldehyde, the bubbling of the solution and the fact that the smell isn't cleared by the addition of a base confirms the fact that it is an aldehyde.

No, formaldehyde and acetaldehyde aren't as similar as you think. You can't generalize organic chemistry to such an extent as you do. Aldehydes undergo several characteristic reactions, why haven't you performed any of them? Also, what was your yield? And do you know what happens to aldehydes in the presence of strong bases?

Quote: Originally posted by weiming1998  
References? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_oxidation
The end product of the oxidation is a carboxylic acid, but you see, the aldehyde is an intermediate product. If you use an excess of the alcohol, more aldehydes are going to be produced instead of carboxylic acids.

Please, I asked for a reference for the oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde by permanganate, not a Wikipedia article about oxidation in general. I know these reactions well, they are after all high school curriculum...

weiming1998 - 30-3-2012 at 01:10

1, not all aldehydes are the same, I know that. But formaldehyde and acetaldehyde has similar chain lengths, and are all derived from monohydric alcohols, so the properties of them should be fairly similar. Aldehydes react with strong bases, but I used a weak base to neutralize, like NaHCO3 or Na2CO3, so there shouldn't be any reaction.

2, According to the Wikipedia page of alcohol oxidation, primary alcohols can be oxidized to either an aldehyde or a carboxylic acid. Methanol is a primary alcohol and KMnO4 can act as the oxidizer in oxidizing primary alcohols. So why can't it be oxidized to an aldehyde? Even if I did not produce any aldehyde in my experiment with the oxidation of ethanol, the article says that the oxidation of a primary alcohol to a carboxylic acid by oxidation has to go by an intermediate stage of an aldehyde hydrate. So, according to the article, the oxidation of a primary alcohol to just an aldehyde can be achieved by oxidizing the alcohol in an anhydrous environment, then bubble the aldehyde produced through water. It might not be perfectly reliable, but it's still worth a try.

testimento - 11-2-2014 at 18:44

Dehydrogenation of methanol on copper or silver catalyst at high temperature is well known process. Would this work as well with platinum with iridium or palladium catalyst? Because there is no risk of over-catalyzing the methanol due to absence of oxygen, the car catalytic converter would be ideal for one step process due to it's massive surface area. It could be insulated and heated to red heat with propane burner and the methanol distilled through it.

A short question for those who don't want to look into the concept: does platinum or palladium work in place of copper/silver in dehydrogenation process?