Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Separation of VO(2+) and Fe(2+/3+)

Altreon - 27-2-2026 at 19:13

I have access to ferrovanadium-85, an alloy of approximately 85% vanadium and 15% iron, and I am trying to separate each element. I have managed to dissolve 10g of the alloy in a 2.5 times molar excess of sulfuric acid along with some peroxide to redissolve light brown V2(SO4)3, which has resulted in a nearly black solution that looks light blue when diluted, with seemingly no trace of the brown of hydrolyzed Fe3+. I then filtered the solution, which left behind a grey gel-like precipitate (insoluble in water, no idea what it is). My plan was to oxidize the VO2+ to VO2+ using H2O2 and filtering out highly insoluble V2O5, but even at room temperature, the peroxide very quickly decomposes, first forming a deep red solution. The deep red complex (peroxovanadyl(V)?) is stable in dilute solution but heating it to decomposition turns the soln. blue instead of yellow.

I'm currently stuck on what to do next. Using (hypo)vanadate for separation is not ideal, because of the amount of base I'd have to add and the possibility that iron forms a really insoluble vanadate. Google says that peroxide is indeed supposed to oxidize VO2+ to VO2+, but this doesn't seem to be working. Coupled with the lack of the strongly colored Fe3+, is there a chance that all the iron is Fe2+, and that it is undergoing the Fenton reaction in a way that catalytically reduces all vanadium(V) to vanadium(IV)? How would I go about preventing this?

Alchemica - 28-2-2026 at 15:42

Just something I saw in my readings that I thought could possibly be of use to simply purify your vanadium compounds, via their ethylene glycol complexes?

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matchemphys.2020.122991





ethylene glycol vandium.jpg - 37kB

teodor - 1-3-2026 at 11:01

I think peroxide is not ideal oxidiser here because of presence of transition metals catalizing the decomposition.
You have sulfates mixture. I am wondering, is it possible to make oxidation/metathesis reaction with ammonium persulfate? Ammonium metavanadate is roughly 80 times less soluble than persulfate.
It could be different results including V2O5 or NH4VO3 precipitation which probably is highly pH dependent.
At high pH (you can try to add KOH + K2S2O8) I would expect potassium metavanadate in solution and Fe(OH)3 precipitation.
So, I propose to use different experiments with potassium and ammonium persulfate, KOH and NH3 solution as well as H2SO4. Mixing in different proportion observe the results and find when you have difference (pH/anion). Than decide what can work for you.
The key points here: 1) NH3 could be oxidised; 2) high pH activate oxidative properties of persulfate.

bnull - 1-3-2026 at 15:48

Is electrolysis an option?

woelen - 2-3-2026 at 04:40

Quote: Originally posted by teodor  
I think peroxide is not ideal oxidiser here because of presence of transition metals catalizing the decomposition.
You have sulfates mixture. I am wondering, is it possible to make oxidation/metathesis reaction with ammonium persulfate? Ammonium metavanadate is roughly 80 times less soluble than persulfate.
It could be different results including V2O5 or NH4VO3 precipitation which probably is highly pH dependent.
At high pH (you can try to add KOH + K2S2O8) I would expect potassium metavanadate in solution and Fe(OH)3 precipitation.
So, I propose to use different experiments with potassium and ammonium persulfate, KOH and NH3 solution as well as H2SO4. Mixing in different proportion observe the results and find when you have difference (pH/anion). Than decide what can work for you.
The key points here: 1) NH3 could be oxidised; 2) high pH activate oxidative properties of persulfate.

I would try with Na2S2O8 as oxidizer. At high pH (13 or higher) you don't get metavanadate, but orthovanadate, VO4(3-). At pH around 11 you get metavanadate, but that ion is not a single entity, it appears to be some polymeric species, which better can be written as [(VO3)n](n-).

At very high pH all iron will precipitate, either as Fe(OH)3, or as FeVO4. In the latter case you lose some vanadium, but most of it will remain in solution. If you boil down the solution, you destroy all residual peroxide and you are left with a (nearly) colorless solution of Na3VO4 with excess sodium and sulfate ions in it. If you carefully lower the pH of this solution to around 2, then you get a bright orange flocculent precipitate of hydrous V2O5. You could try to collect that precipitate and then redissolve this in as little as possible of solution of NaOH. Boiling down that solution gives you NaVO3, mixed with Na3VO4. Precise stoichiometry will be hard to obtain, but at least you then have something, which only contains vanadium(V) and sodium as main metallic species.

See also here: https://woelen.homescience.net/science/chem/solutions/v.html

Altreon - 2-3-2026 at 05:18

I unfortunately don't have access to persulfates, and my solution contains VO2+ so without an oxidizer I can't use the insolubility of NH4VO3 to achieve anything. The only other strongly oxidizing reagent I have is KMnO4, but that would introduce a third metal into the mix.

V2+ is impossible to reduce in aqueous environment. I do not know anything about electrowinning in non-aqueous conditions. Even if I focused on reduction of iron, electrolysis is just such a costly process for 8.5g of metal. In theory I could also use Zn to reduce Fe but that seems like a waste of Zn (it would also reduce the V)

That ethylene glycol complex seems to be on the cutting edge of vanadium chemistry, and I could not find any sources detailing its synthesis from a vanadium(IV) precursor (the reactions proceed using ammonium metavanadate), and I could not find info about the solvent used in its synthesis.

As a side note, I tried adding freezing the soln. and adding H2O2, but upon warming to room temp the red color degrades into brown, very dark green(???), then dark blue, and I have seen most of these colors before. It seems that H2O2 really can't oxidize VO2+ in acidic soln.

I've given up and added 8 equivalents of KOH to neutralize all the sulfuric acid and create a solution of vanadates. For some reason the black gel in soln. did not dissolve despite lots of KOH, but it is much easier to oxidize with peroxide, turning from brown (hypovanadate?) with a black gel to yellow with a brown gel, probably Fe(OH)3. Despite boiling the black gel for 2 hours, it is very voluminous and pretty much impossible to filter without access to vacuum, especially considering the strongly alkaline conditions, so I may have to discard and repeat this synthesis. (Is there a reason why Fe(OH)3 is so hard to filter in excess alkali? It doesn't dissolve in it AFAIK....)

[Edited on 2-3-2026 by Altreon]